What Should I Throw?

Tell me the lake and the conditions and I'll tell you what I'd tie on — the technique, the lure, colors, depth and retrieve, and why. It's Bryan's decision-making, drawn from the knowledge base.

Here's what I'd throw on Lake Buchanan

On Lake Buchanan, throw a Football Jig — green pumpkin, brown.

Evidence: Assembled from 1 knowledge objects (lake, season, conditions, techniques, lures) in Bryan Cotter's Central Texas bass knowledge base.
Related: Football Jig technique · Football Jig guide · Lake Buchanan lake guide

High Answered by , Texas Hawgs guide · Updated Jul 12, 2026

Colors: green pumpkin, brown.

Depth: 8-30 ft.

Retrieve: Slow bottom drag with the rod, pausing at rocks; the head keeps the trailer standing like a feeding craw.

From Bryan's logbook

The number one thing I look for on Buchanan is rock - the largemouth love it, partly because it lets them tuck away from the striper, and the best rock holds the best fish. In cold water, when you think you're fishing slow enough, slow down more; that's how the giants come.
— Bryan Cotter · winter

Also good: Crankbait Fishing, Swimbait Fishing, Shaky Head.

89% confidenceSources: Bryan Cotter's first-hand experienceUpdated Jul 11, 2026

Assembled from 1 knowledge objects.

What's been working lately

From 4 Lake Buchanan reports · latest Dec 4, 2020. See the reports →

Want to see it done right? Book a trip and I'll put the rod in your hand. Rates & booking or call 512-762-0190.

← Start over · Lake Finder · Recent fishing reports